Seven employees allege discrimination and retaliation after seeking recognition for Jewish heritage and organizing a gathering to mourn victims of the Bondi Beach Chanukah massacre.
What began as an effort by Jewish New York City Health Department employees to celebrate their heritage became a federal discrimination lawsuit after their proposed cultural group was denied recognition and eight leaders were investigated following a gathering to mourn victims of an anti-Semitic terrorist attack.
Seven employees filed the 110-page complaint on November 10 through the National Jewish Advocacy Center (NJAC), accusing the city, its Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH), and Equal Employment Opportunity Director Sye-Eun Ahn of discrimination, retaliation, and fostering a hostile workplace.
The dispute began in July 2025, when employees sought recognition for HINENU, a Jewish Employee Resource Group whose Hebrew name means “Here We Are.”
DOHMH recognized six other employee groups representing various cultural and identity communities, providing them with agency email accounts, communications resources, calendar access, and annual $5,000 budgets.
HINENU proposed programming exploring Jewish history, ancestry, and traditions, including Ashkenazic, Sephardic, Mizrachi, Ethiopian, Bukharian, and Persian heritage, with membership open to all employees.
At a July 16 meeting, however, department officials refused to permit a Jewish group, citing restrictions on religiously based organizations.
Employees argued that their proposal concerned Jewish peoplehood and cultural heritage, not religion or politics. They pointed to DOHMH’s recognition of ASWATNA, representing people of Southwest Asian and North African ancestry across multiple religions.
The dispute intensified following the December 14, 2025, terrorist attack at Sydney’s Bondi Beach, where two gunmen murdered 15 people attending a Chanukah celebration.
On December 16, HINENU emailed approximately 85 colleagues mourning the victims and inviting employees to an online support gathering. The message included remarks by Rabbi Chaim Steinmetz of Manhattan’s Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun condemning calls to “globalize the intifada” and warning that anti-Zionism had contributed to violence against Jews.
Organizers subsequently asked department officials to acknowledge anti-Semitism agency-wide, arrange counseling with a professional familiar with Jewish trauma, and publicize the gathering.
Within hours, Ahn instructed HINENU to stop using its agency email account, which organizers said another official had authorized.
On December 18, approximately 15 or 16 employees attended the online gathering. Without the requested counselor, HINENU’s leaders facilitated a discussion about armed guards outside shuls and schools, fears of wearing a yarmulke publicly, and gratitude toward bystanders who intervened during the massacre.
According to the lawsuit, department leadership waited until December 29 to decline the requested agency-wide acknowledgment and refer employees to the city’s general Employee Assistance Program. The next day, HINENU was instructed to suspend activities pending a policy review.
Other unrecognized groups allegedly continued operating. In January, HINENU sought clarification after learning that Haitian, climate-related, and global oppression groups were holding events. Its proposed Tu BiShvat program received no substantive response.
On February 3, 2026, DOHMH hosted a presentation titled “Challenges of Advancing Public Health in Occupied Territory” at its Long Island City headquarters, attracting more than 100 participants.
According to the complaint, organizers linked the program to allegations of genocide in Palestine. Plaintiffs objected to official workplace channels being used to criticize Israel while Jewish cultural activities remained restricted.
The lawsuit also cites DOHMH’s January 27 International Holocaust Remembrance Day message, which encouraged employees to confront allegations of genocide in Gaza, Myanmar, and Sudan. HINENU organizers objected, arguing that the language diminished the particular history of anti-Semitism and the Holocaust.
Professional counseling was finally arranged on February 10 through HINENU founder Tamar Pacht, nearly two months after the massacre. According to the complaint, only HINENU leaders attended. A second session, on April 13, drew more participants, although several reportedly hesitated to speak openly.
By then, eight HINENU leaders were under investigation following complaints from 14 colleagues, most of whom allegedly had neither received the original email nor attended the gathering.
During compulsory April interviews, investigators questioned employees about Zionism, Israel, and “globalize the intifada,” including whether describing such rhetoric as threatening could constitute discrimination against Arab or Muslim colleagues.
When an attorney objected that the questioning concerned personal beliefs rather than workplace misconduct, Ahn responded that there was no due process at that stage and insisted on cooperation.
On June 24, after 117 days, the investigation closed without findings. The department said it could not determine whether discrimination occurred without adopting definitive interpretations of disputed political terminology.
Six days later, HINENU submitted a 14-page application listing 18 interested employees, more than three times the required minimum. Its charter defined Jewish identity through ancestry, history, and culture while excluding religious worship, instruction, and political advocacy.
Nevertheless, on July 10, Ahn rejected the application in one sentence: “As stated in the ERG Guidelines, ERG identity cannot be based on religious groups.”
Plaintiffs contrast that decision with DOHMH’s authorization of Ramadan-related guidance through ASWATNA and its engagement with Orthodox Jewish communities through a Haredi Health Coalition.
The complaint further alleges a pattern of anti-Israel messaging since the October 7, 2023, Hamas attacks, including internal communications describing Israel as colonialist and apartheid, workplace materials alleging genocide, and a recorded training session reportedly characterizing the October 7 massacre as armed resistance.
The lawsuit also cites Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s statements and policies concerning Israel as contributing to the alleged workplace climate.
The lawsuit seeks HINENU’s official recognition, removal of the investigation from their employment records, and monetary damages under federal, state, and city civil rights protections.
NJAC CEO Mark Goldfeder summarized the organization’s position: “The City told its Jewish employees that every identity counts except theirs, then investigated them for grieving.”
By Shabsie Saphirstein
