Congresswoman Grace Meng Responds To Jewish Community

“And the Canaanite king of Arad who dwelled in the south heard that Israel had come by the route of the spies, and he waged war against Israel and took a captive from it.”

BaMidbar 21:1

The Reputation of Yisrael

When Hashem took the Jewish Nation out of Mitzrayim with an “outstretched arm,” most of Creation welcomed the news as a defining moment in history. The nation of Amaleik, however, laid plans to attack Yisrael. The pasuk describes the “Canaanite king” who sat in the south and heard that Yisrael was coming. But Rashi points out that it wasn’t the Canaanite nation that lived in the south of Israel; it was Amaleik. Why are they referred to as the “Canaanites?”

Rashi answers that, according to the Midrash, the nation that attacked was Amaleik. However, when they came close, they stopped speaking their mother tongue and switched to the language of Canaan. Their reasoning was that the Jews would hear them speaking and would assume that it was Canaan that was attacking them. The Jews would then daven to Hashem to save them “from Canaan.” Since these opponents were not from Canaan, the t’filah wouldn’t work. But their plan failed because the Jews recognized something unusual. Yes, their enemies were speaking the language of Canaan, but they were dressed as Amaleikim. Therefore, the Jews davened in neutral language: “Hashem, save us from this nation.” As a result, their t’filah was effective.

The Question

It is clear from this Rashi that, had B’nei Yisroel davened incorrectly and said, “Hashem save us from Canaan,” their tefillah would not have worked. However, they were saved because they realized the trick and davened in a manner that included all possibilities.

This Rashi is very difficult to understand. What difference would it make what expression the Jews used? Hashem would know what they meant. The Jewish nation was in trouble, faced with an enemy attacking, and they called out to their Creator. Why would it matter whether they referred to the attackers as Canaan or Amalek? Hashem would know what they were referring to; and if they were worthy of being saved, Hashem would listen.

The answer to this question cuts to the very underpinning of how prayer works.

Why Daven?

One of the most basic question that a person should ask about t’filah in general is “Why should we daven?” Hashem is the ultimate Giver. Hashem is infinitely more generous and benevolent than any person. He loves every one of His creations more than we can ever imagine. That being said, why should we ask Hashem for anything? If what we are asking for is truly good for us, then Hashem would have given it to us already. And if it isn’t good for us, why should we ask for it?

The answer to this question is based on understanding that t’filah functions in three distinct systems.

The Growth System

The first is the “Growth System.” By davening, we change ourselves. T’filah is a method that allows us to recognize certain truths and to live them.

The reality is that we mortals get caught up in the ways of nature and tend to forget that Hashem is present and that it is He who runs the world. When we need something and recognize that we are incapable of filling that need, this forces us to reach out to our Creator. We then come to the core realization that He alone is in charge. That process changes us and helps us grow. So, it could well be that before we davened, we weren’t worthy of having our requests granted, but via the process of davening we changed, and now we merit it. For this reason, Hashem will often hold back things specifically so that man should ask, because that is what he needs to grow. This is the first system of prayer, whereby a person changes as a result of davening.

The Mercy System

The second system of davening is the “Mercy System.” Our relationship with Hashem is that of a child to a father. He loves us and has great compassion on us. The second system of davening takes advantage of that relationship. We call out to Hashem to help us not because we are worthy, but rather as a son who calls out to his father and asks him to have mercy. This system recognizes that we may well not be worthy of receiving that which we ask for, not before davening nor after, but we ask Hashem to overlook who we are and to give us what we need. We attempt to arouse the midah of rachamim.

The Avodah System

Chazal tell us that Hashem said to Moshe, “I will teach you something that you will need to know as the leader of this nation. There will be times when the Jewish people will be in trouble, and even their own merit and the merit of the Avos will not help them. When this happens, you are to call out the Thirteen Attributes of Hashem. Say the words, ‘Hashem, Hashem, Keil rachum v’chanun…’ and I will forgive their sins.”

The question is: How does this work? Klal Yisrael didn’t change via that t’filah. They didn’t become more worthy because of it, and if it is just an issue of arousing Hashem’s mercy, why those specific words, said in that specific manner?

The answer to this is that Hashem created certain systems of avodah that affect the world. Just as there are laws of nature and physical actions that affect the world, so, too, Hashem created an upper world, and various actions affect it. In the time of the Beis HaMikdash, if a person lived through a Yom Kippur, the korbanos of that day brought him forgiveness. Even if he wasn’t attuned to what was going on, even if he wasn’t in Yerushalayim, and even if he slept through the entire day, just the fact that he was alive while the Kohen Gadol did the avodah brought him a certain level of forgiveness for his sins.

However, there are certain rules to the system. The process is demanding and exact. Any deviation and it doesn’t work. Much like an otherwise-perfect radio can’t function if it is missing just one transistor, so too with the avodah. Any missing detail and the system doesn’t function.

This seems to be the answer to this Rashi. The Amaleikim were very sophisticated and were aware of the powerful functioning of the upper world, and they did their best to interrupt the Jews’ use of that system. They tried to trick the Jews so that they would daven incorrectly and thereby negate the third system of t’filah, which might have made all the difference as to whether the t’filah worked.

Even though the Jews davened with kavanah and Hashem knew what they meant, that t’filah would not have carried the full power, because it was inaccurate and couldn’t utilize the third system of davening.

This concept is very relevant to us. While we strive to make our davening passionate and vibrant, the reality is that there will be occasions when we will find it difficult to concentrate or to feel a real emotional connection to Hashem. It is at those times that we need to remember that Chazal used a highly defined system to create the t’filos that we say. The effect of the words themselves is well beyond anything that we can imagine. While it is not the ultimate goal in davening, just mouthing the words can have a huge impact and change our destiny.


Born and bred in Kew Gardens Hills, R’ Ben Tzion Shafier joined the Choftez Chaim Yeshiva after high school. Shortly thereafter he got married and moved with his new family to Rochester, where he remained in for 12 years. R’ Shafier then moved to Monsey, NY, where he was a Rebbe in the new Chofetz Chaim branch there for three years. Upon the Rosh Yeshiva’s request, he stopped teaching to devote his time to running Tiferes Bnei Torah. R” Shafier, a happily married father of six children, currently resides in Monsey.